Village of Baldwinsville
Architectural Review Board Meeting Minutes
Monday, June 6, 2022, at 7:00pm     

Present:	Mr. Dean Johnson, Chairman
Mr. Bruce King
Mr. Mark Jenkins
Ms. Peg Halleron

Mr. Jim Orlando was unable to attend this evening’s meeting.
Guests: Jeff Rogers-owner of the Angry Smokehouse, via Zoom                              
Also:  Mary Augustus, ARB Secretary Via Zoom
           Gregg Humphrey, Code Enforcement Officer
Minutes from March 7, 2022, were Tabled by Chairman Johnson

33 Water Street- Angry Smokehouse/exterior 

Mr. Jeff Rodgers, new owner of the Angry Smokehouse was present this evening by Zoom to answer any questions from the Board.  Mr. Rodgers is remodeling the Lock 24 Restaurant at 33 Water Street.  He decided on two colors for the exterior of the building not understanding he should have presented this to the Architectural Review Board prior to painting.  The two colors he picked were Behr, “No More Drama” #P140-7 for the main building and Behr, “Blackout” #N510-7 for the window trim and doors.
Mr. Johnson asked the Board if they had reviewed the application presented for 33 Water Street?  Mr. Johnson stated the color is not a pre-approved pallet color, but that is not always necessary. Mr. King stated he would like to compare the color used on the building to the Village pre-approved colors.   
The Board asked if Mr. Rodgers intent was to paint the light tower also? He stated the entire building will be the same color. Mr. Humphrey explained that Mr. Rodgers stopped the paint when it was brought to his attention about coming before the ARB.  There is exterior work that must be done to the building prior to finishing the painting especially the light tower.  
Mr. King stated he thinks diversity is important, with that said, the Board has been fairly ridge-it about using the pre-approved paint color pallet and not to go too far from the approved color pallet.  He was wondering if this color was too far.  He continued, that the color should be consistent, complimentary, and harmonious to the already scheme established in the area.  Mr. King continued, he is not sure the surrounding buildings would or would not comfortably fit with this color. He added that the color pallet would reflect the 1900 century, although we are removed from that era.  Mr. King stated it was wonderful to see something done with this building.  Ms. Halleron agreed it was nice to see the progress.  Mr. Johnson stated this color is “border line”.  
Mr. Rodgers stated he thought it was a nice concept to go with the Baldwinsville school colors and the color represented a smokehouse theme. Again Mr. Rodgers apologized for not getting approval before starting the painting project.  He assumed since he was not in a historical area and outside the business district and not belonging to an HOA he could use this color.  He continued that 80 percent of the building is paint and he has received nothing but positive reactions from the Baldwinsville resident on its appearance.  Mr. Rodgers stated there are quite a few buildings with bold color, the B’ville Diner for example has 3 bold colors.

Motion by Mr. Johnson to approve the application as submitted, second by Mr. Jenkins   

Mr. Johnson	Yes
Mr. Jenkins	Yes
Ms. Halleron	Yes
Mr. King	No
                                            Carried 3:1

Mr. Humphrey suggested the Board review the exterior lighting for the sign.  Mr. Rodgers stated it is a traditional goose neck style lighting.  These lights are identical to the light installed at the Angry Garlic. The lights are black with LED, hung above a non-illuminated sign. The sign 9-foot round sign on the front of the building and a 7-foot round on the side of the building.  The signs will be done by John McFall. 

18 E. Genesee Street- WT Brews 

Mr. Michael Johnson was not in attendance for this evening’s meeting.  WT Brews is located at 18 E. Genesee Street.  Mr. Johnson has been approved by the Planning Board to have an addition constructed onto the existing building.  This is 24’ x 10’, 240 square foot addition that will be used as a kitchen.  The site plan shows a composite clapboard siding and a white 29-gauge steel roof to match the existing building which was already approved by this Board.  Mr. Humphrey stated the only question is the roof.  Mr. Johnson proposed a corrugated screwed on metal roof, to match the overhang at the delivery door.  Mr. Humphrey continued, that most of the buildings in the Village have standing seam metal roofs.  Mr. King stated the roof is not a large roof on the addition and feels the Board should request a standing seam or a non-exposed fastener. Mr. Johnson agreed the color of the metal roof should match the existing color.     
           
Motion by Mr. Johnson to approve the application as submitted, with the exception the roof should be a non-exposed fastener second by Mr. King   
    
                                               Carried 4:0

Motion by Mr. Johnson to adjourn the meeting at 7:34pm, second by Ms. Halleron
The next meeting is scheduled for Tuesday July 5, 2022, at 7:00pm 
Respectfully Submitted, 
Mary E. Augustus
ARB Secretary